Chapter 2 - The Stranger in the Grey Overcoat
The man standing outside the bakery window did not look away. He wore a heavy grey overcoat that seemed entirely too warm for the crisp afternoon air, and his face drained of all color as Lily’s words echoed through the glass. He pressed his palms flat against the cold storefront, his eyes locked onto the elderly grandfather leaning on the wooden cane. Inside, the baker watched with a strange, knowing smirk, leaning his hip against the stainless steel register. Lily stood frozen, her silver shoes firmly planted on the tiled floor, waiting to see if anyone would step forward from the busy downtown crowd.
“Come on, sweetheart,” the grandfather whispered gently, his voice raspy and frail. “We cannot ask strangers for such expensive things. Let us go home.”
“No, Grandpa,” Lily whispered fiercely, turning back to the baker. “You said if they follow, you give it to us.”
“That was the deal,” the baker replied, his voice echoing loudly in the quiet shop. “One person. Just one soul from that street needs to walk through my door and acknowledge you. If they do, the cake is yours. If they don’t, you take your old man and walk back out into the cold.”
The man in the grey overcoat slowly reached for the brass handle of the bakery door. His fingers trembled as he pulled it open, the brass bell above the threshold chiming with a sharp, piercing ring that made everyone inside turn in unison. The stranger stepped inside, the chill of the autumn wind rolling in behind him. He did not look at the baker. He did not look at the magnificent blue and white cake. His eyes were fixed entirely on the elderly man’s cane, specifically on the brass engraving near the curved handle.
“You,” the man in the overcoat whispered, his voice catching in his throat as he took a slow, deliberate step forward. “You’re supposed to be in Chicago.”
The grandfather slowly lifted his head, his cloudy eyes narrowing as he studied the stranger’s face for the first time in five years. A slow, terrifying realization washed over the old man's features, making him grip his wooden cane so tightly that his knuckles bruised.
May you like
“And you,” the grandfather rasped back, his voice dropping to a harsh whisper. “Weren’t supposed to find us.”
---
